Showing posts with label Terry Freedman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Terry Freedman. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 12, 2018

Cracking the code: the world of crosswords

There is a common misperception that the 'quick' crossword is easier than the cryptic crossword. Yet a moment's reflection should be sufficient to dispel this myth. The so-called 'quick' crossword – which is perhaps better referred to as 'straight' – is neither quick nor easy. The fact that people believe it is simply suggests that they have been lucky.
Cryptic crossword, by Terry Freedman
Cryptic crossword, by Terry Freedman

This type of crossword relies on two things for its completion: a knowledge of synonyms, and mind-reading. While it is true, as someone put it, that there are no synonyms in English, there are certainly enough near-synonyms to choose from when it comes to crosswords.

Take, for instance, this clue:

Achieved (3)

What answer is the compiler looking for? Won? Got? Did? Any of these is possible. Indeed, a colleague told me in 1979 that a man he'd met in the pub the night before was having trouble getting the very last clue of his (straight) crossword. It transpired that the reason for the impasse was that, incredibly, answers to all the other clues were wrong.

This could almost certainly never happen with a cryptic crossword because each clue consists of two parts rather than one: the definition of the answer, which is equivalent to the clue in the quick crossword, and a secondary indicator which tells you how to arrive at the answer. You just have to understand the strange mangling of the English language that comprises the crossword code. As the compiler Afrit put it:

"You need not mean what you say, but you must say what you mean."
Let's take a few examples. First:

Egyptian flower (4)

You might be wondering, what kind of flower grows in Egypt? A Rose? An Iris? And in so doing you would get precisely nowhere. But think of flower as rhyming with lower, you realize it is something which flows, ie a river, and you deduce the answer immediately: Nile.

Having mentioned the word 'lower', perhaps we might try this:

A little lower on the farm (4)

If you start thinking in terms of height, you may as well abandon all hope. Just as a flower in the first clue referred to something that flows, so a lower in this clue refers to something that lows, ie a cow or a bull. Clearly, a little lower is a calf.

Before we leave this farm, consider this:

Farm butter (4)

As you may have surmised, a butter in 'crosswordese' is something which butts – in this case a goat.

These are examples of the compiler deliberately setting out to draw you into making a false assumption, from which point it is all downhill unless and until you can step back and realise that is exactly what you've done.

Other clues have more obvious indicators. For example, "all over the place" or "disconcerted" would indicate an anagram:

Such an event would disconcert astronomers (2,4,5)

The word "disconcerted" indicates that the answer is an anagram of "astronomers". The answer is: No more stars.

Other indicators include:

Detailed – meaning the end of the word has been cut off ie de-tailed.

Beheaded – the first letter of the word has been chopped off.

Midnight – that is, the middle of the word "night", ie "g".

Finally, crossword compilers have a great sense of humour. Some years ago the Daily Telegraph crossword featured the following clue:

What an incompetent deep sea diver must do to get rid of an irritation? (4,2,2,7)

(A question mark at the end of the clue, by the way, indicates a mangling of the language that will cause the solver to groan.)

The answer? Come up to scratch.

It has been said that the job of the cryptic crossword compiler is to lose the battle gracefully. The 'battle' is one of wits between the compiler and the solver, and there is little that is more pleasurable than solving a really good clue. 

Except, of course, solving the whole puzzle.

Friday, May 28, 2010

Mind Your Language -- 5: Fork Handles

This is a marvellous observation of what can happen when communication is not as clear as it might be.


Thursday, May 27, 2010

Mind your Language -- 4: Cryptic Crosswords

If, like me, you have a love of language, you should explore the strange world of the cryptic crossword. Unlike the plain crossword, the cryptic variety requires more than providing a synonym for a word or phrase. Rather, it involves working out what the clue is getting at.

That sounds much more difficult than the task facing you in an ordinary crossword, doesn't it? In fact, much of the time it's easier, for one simple reason. In a plain crossword, you either know the answer or you don't. With a cryptic one, on the other hand, you have a chance of working the answer out from the clue. Indeed, on many occasions I have worked out the answer to be a word that I've never heard of, which means, of course, that I'd never have got the answer in a plain crossword setting.

Let me give you an example. Let's suppose the word to be entered into the grid is candle. In a normal crossword, the clue might be something like:

Type of illumination (6) (The number represents the number of letters in the answer.)

In the hands of the cryptic cruciverbalist, however, the clue might read something like this:

It is wicked, but it gives light (6).

What's that you say? Wicked? What's good and bad got to do with it? Well actually, nothing, but before explaining why, I should deconstruct the sentence.

Like most cryptic clues, this consists of two parts: a definition, ie the meaning of the word or phrase that is the answer, and an indication of how to work the answer out. In this case, the definition is "it gives light". In other words, the answer is an object which gives light, so it could be a torch, candle, flare, sun, moon, neon light and so on. The indication part of the clue, though, helps us narrow it down by informing us that the object we're looking for is wicked, ie it has a wick.

That's a classic trick of the cryptic crossword clue: you mustn't take anything at face value! Here, the correct pronunciation of the word is not wick-ed but wick'd. Makes perfect sense, right?

Other examples include "flower", pronounced floe-er, ie something that flows, ie a river. Thus "Egyptian flower (4)" is not asking for the name of a plant, but the name of a river, ie the Nile.

Perhaps an even worse example of this stretching the rules of language to their limit is the word "banker". That's not someone who works in the City or on Wall Street, but something that has banks, ie a river.

What do you understand by the word "detailed"? Well you're wrong. In the land of the cryptic crossword, "detailed" means having had its tail remove. That would usually mean that the end of the word has been removed.

So it won't surprise you to learn that "beheaded" means having had the first letter of the word removed.

Anagrams are indicated by a word or phrase which suggests the letters have been jumbled up: "all over the place"; "agitated"; "confused" and so on.

What makes the cryptic crossword especially challenging is that the clue makes sense in itself. That often leads the solver to make certain assumptions, and thereby to be led completely up the garden path. And the answer will often make you groan out loud, such as a clue I saw recently in the Daily Telegraph, which was something like:

"Is this the central part of our education system? (6,6)"

(A question mark usually indicates that there has been a complete mangling of the meaning of a word or phrase.)

The answer was "Middle School".

It's this sort of challenge and playfulness which makes cryptic crosswords fun to do.

My favourite crossword clue of all time appeared in the Daily Telegraph about 30 years ago. It read something like:

"What an incompetent deep sea diver must do to get rid of an irritation? (4,2,2,7)"

The answer? Come up to scratch.

To find out more about cryptic crosswords, follow the links below. You might also like to read this book, which interweaves crossword clues with the story:

Pretty Girl in Crimson Rose (8): A Memoir of Love, Exile and Crosswords

The title is itself a cryptic crossword clue: "pretty girl" is "belle"; "crimson" is "red". Those are the clues provided for the definition, which is "rose" -- but not the flower, but the act of revolting against a a ruler. Hence the answer is "Rebelled", because you have to place the word "belle" (pretty girl) inside the word "red" (crimson).

This nicely illustrates the point I made earlier, about the clue making sense but thereby leading you in completely the wrong direction. When you read the sentence "Pretty girl in crimson rose", you are almost bound to conjure up a mental picture of an attractive young lady wearing a dress of a crimson rose colour. Completely wrong!

Have fun!

See also Mind Your Language --3.

Related articles by Zemanta
How to Solve Cryptic Crosswords
Exploring the Fascinating World of Crossword Puzzles on your Kindle

Friday, January 22, 2010

Waiting


This is my first attempt at Twitter fiction.

Jason Fox surveyed the street. Something looked wrong, out of place. He waited. A phone screen flickered alive. Not long now.

Wednesday, December 03, 2008

More on the Online Information conference

Everything is a balancing act. Take this morning, for instance. I was faced with the choice between racing to get a particular session, or taking some time to consolidate some of my notes from yesterday at the conference and responding to emails from clients.

I decided to opt for the more leisurely course of action. This was mainly because I think it's important to respond to clients and potential clients in a timely way (well, I try to do so with everyone actually), and partly because of the way the conference sessions have been orgaised. There are two or three sessions one after the other in each room at a particular time, and it's hard to try and barge in at the appropriate time if the one you're interested in happens to be on last. Yesterday I had to sit through a couple of dire sessions, and frankly I didn't want to risk the same thing happening today, when there were other things I could (and should) be getting on with.

Having said that, I also attended a couple of cracking sessions, including one by Jenny Levine on what libraries are doing in the world of Web 2.0 (a lot for schools to learn from this), and Marydee Ojaha on searching the web (ditto). I will be writing more about these very soon, on the ICT in Education site.

And now, having been fed, watered and energised by writing this blog, I'm about to line up for a seminar.

More later, but in the meantime if you want to follow the conference in Twitter the commonly-accepted hashtags are #onlineinfo and #onlineinfo08.

Tuesday, December 02, 2008

Collaborating just got easier

That's the message from Clay Shirkey in his opening keynote talk at the Online Information conference here in London.

I don't have time to write an extensive report just at the moment, but for now I will leave you with this thought:

"Journalism has moved from being a profession to being an activity. People commit acts of journalism."

I love that, even though I am not sure I wholeheartedly agree with it. And I think it ties in tio what I have started to explore in my survey of the differences between writing and blogging.

Well, on the next stage of the proceedings, which is to look at the seminar list, conference sessions list and exhibitors' list, to determine where to go next.

I will be writing more about the keynote and the rest of today either later tonight or tomorrow, at the ICT in Education website.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Stationary item

Monday, 15 September 2008. I've had a reprieve! No, no, not from prison, but from a ban on buying pens and paper. To think, that having spent years evaluating the usefulness of conferences by the (a) number and (b) the quality of the freebies I manage to come home with, my "reward" was to be told:

"We've got enough pens to open a stationery shop",

followed by a blanket ban on anything even remotely resembling a writing implement. There's gratitude for you.

Now here's a funny thing. Despite being a technofile, I love the feel of paper, and I love writing with nice pens. When I was 15 I fell in love with, bought, and fell in love with all over again, a clutch pencil that lasted for years. I've even still got some of the leads for it. Relatively recently, I discovered (though not sure how) that I still love a nice pencil. In particular, I love writing ideas for articles in a notebook, with a pencil.

I actually don't know why I like using a pencil, rather than a pen, for this. It is certainly not so that I can erase it or bits of it -- I tend to just cross it through. It just, I don't know, feels right.

A couple of weeks ago I was allowed to treat myself to a special pocket notebook in which to record my ideas. A special, dedicated notebook, with squared paper, that is completely separate from the other notebook I use to make to-do lists whilst on the bus or train, or for note-taking in meetings. But my joy was not complete because I also had to carry around either an ordinary pencil or a cheap clutch pencil that was a freebie at some away day or other, and is so light as to be almost insubstantial.

PencilBut today I had a reprieve. On our travels, my wife and I saw a lovely-looking Cross ball pen and pencil set. Black and silver, not too expensive, and with a lifetime guarantee. Taking a leaf out of our cats' books, I looked at her imploringly. In a moment of weakness, she succumbed to my charms. I am now the proud owner of this wonderful propelling pencil. It has weight. It has gravitas. It has a 9mm lead.

Unfortunately, it is so lovely that I cannot bear the thought of losing it, or worse. And so, it remains on my desk, a stationary stationery item, whilst I sit on the bus with my squared notebook and flimsy clutch pencil.

You'd think, being a technofile, I'd use technology to record my ideas. There's a memo function on my mobile phone, and a voice recording function too. I could use either of those, or a laptop. But it's not the same. There is something about the act of writing an idea that renders it more beautiful than merely typing it, texting it, or recording it. And besides, a notebook and pencil is less fiddly, less likely to be "wiped", and certainly less likely to attract muggers.

So, what are all these ideas for? I'm doing lots of writing at the moment. As well as my own website and a blog I use for writing about writing, I write a blog for Technology and Learning and one for Hot Chalk, as well as articles for the TES now and again.

I just enjoy writing. And blogging. Which reminds me. I'm conducting a survey into what people think are the differences (if any) between writing and blogging. If you have an opinion on the matter, and a spare five minutes in which to express it, it would be good to hear your views.

Saturday, March 31, 2007

Book Review: 12 Books That Changed The World

I'm reading a really interesting book at the moment. Note the present participle: I haven't finished it yet, so regard this as an interim review -- I'll let you know if I change my mind once I've read to the end.

"12 Books That Changed The World" starts from the premise that words, writing, can be just as powerful as the bomb or the bullet when it comes to causing cataclysmic change -- perhaps even more so. Books may be less immediately dramatic, but their effects, like ripples in the pond of time, can spread far and wide.

Unlike some popular, or should I say populist, books, this is not a one trick pony. What do I mean by that? Well, despite all the hype and the idol-worship, I can think of at least three books that consists of basically one idea repeated 50 times: The World Is Flat, by Thomas Friedman; Blink, by Malcolm Gladwell; and The Long Tail, by Chris Anderson.

Now, you could, of course, argue that "12 Books..." falls into the same trap, except that the single idea is repeated only 12 times. And you would be correct, looked at from one point of view. However, because the subject matter is so eclectic, the examples feel different -- very different.

So, what are the great works that are covered by the book? The selection -- and it is a selection: the author is at pains to tell us that he doesn't regard this as a list of the 12 books that changed the world -- may surprise you. In fact, the title would almost have been more accurate had it been "12 ideas that changed the world", but even that would not have been quite right. The books in question are:

  • Principia Mathematica -- Isaac Newton
  • Married Love -- Marie Stopes
  • Magna Carta -- English Ruling Classes
  • The Rule Book of Association Football -- ex-public schoolboys
  • On the Origin of Species -- Charles Darwin
  • On the Abolition of the Slave Trade -- William Wilberforce
  • A Vindication of the Rights of Women -- Mary Wollstonecraft
  • Experimental Researches on Electricity -- Michael Faraday
  • Patnt Specification for Arkwright's Spinning Machine -- Richard Arkwright
  • The King James Bible -- William Tyndale et al
  • An Enquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations -- Adam Smith
  • The First Folio -- William Shakespeare.


As you would expect from Melvyn Bragg, if you have ever watched his TV series, the book is intellectually stimulating, exciting even, yet curiously understated. To take just one example: I am not a football fan myself and, apart from accidentally watching exciting games now and again, can pretty much take or leave it. Yet it never occurred to me that before the rule book was written, there were no rules. Obvious, really, once someone has pointed it out. And who would have thought that failure to agree on the inclusion of one or two rules would lead to the resignation of one of the committee members, or that the basic set of rules was written down one evening in a pub? And were you aware, as I was not, that the term "soccer" derives from "Association", as in Football Association, or that Rugby was, originally, called football, but had a different set of rules?

So far, what I've gained from the book is not merely a collection of facts such as these, but yet more proof of the power of the human spirit, and the bravery of particular individuals when they dared to challenge the conventional wisdom of their day.

There is included in the book a quote from Sir Isaac Newton which I love, because it reflects the fascination I feel at the fact that all the stuff we use now and take for granted relies on laws and energies that were always present, but undiscovered. I often wonder to myself what natural "raw materials" people in 50, 200 or 1000 years' time will be using of which we presently have no knowledge. He said:

"I do not know what I may appear to the world, but to myself I seem to have been only like a boy playing on the sea-shore, and diverting myself now and then finding a smoother pebble or a prettier shell than ordinary, whilst the great ocean of truth lay all unknown before me."

If you love good writing and great ideas, treat yourself: buy this book.




Saturday, March 24, 2007

Zoundry Test


I've just downloaded and installed a program called Zoundry, a WYSIWYG editor for creating, and then publishing, blog entries.


So far it seems OK, apart from the annoying fact that a tag box simply will not go away. I like the fact that it has a spell-checker, activated by F7, which I am used to, and that it automatically downloaded and installed a UK dictionary.


You can use different types of tag -- I am using Technorati. But it's a shame that you can only use one type at a time, and that it's too easy to get rid of your list of tags: I am about to type them in for the third time!


I have to say that I'm impressed by the fact that it downloaded my previous entries, which makes editing them a piece of cake: I can do it all from my desktop instead of going into Blogger. And that's another thing: after Google had finished messing about with all the account settings, my Windows Live Writer would no longer connect to my blog. This one had no trouble at all.




Technorati : ,

Saturday, January 20, 2007

Publishing, Self-Publishing and Vanity Publishing

In this first video in this mini-series, I explain why I decided to self-publish my latest two books rather than attempt to have them published by a commercial publisher. The two books are Every Child Matters: What it Means for the ICT Teacher, and Go, On, Bore 'Em: How to Make ICT Lessons Excruciatingly Dull.

These booklets now available!!! Click the pix for more info!

Every Child Matters Go on, bore 'em

Reviews of these
books



Click to play the video.

Monday, January 01, 2007

Living in Two Worlds

The lady diagonally opposite the person I visit in hospital lives in a world of her own, pretty much. We all do, to some extent, but most of us share enough of our perception with others to be able to engage in social intercourse on a more or less equal footing. For this particular person, that doesn't seem to be the case.

She spends much of her time having conversations with people who are not there. Because they are not there, they cannot respond to her wishes. For example, a few days ago she was asking the other person to help her on with her shoes. When the other person didn't respond, she became agitated, distressed.

"What have I ever done to you," she wailed, "that you won't even help me on with my shoes?"

Interestingly, she draws other people in to her world in much the same way that I draw events into my dreams. For example, when, in a dream, a bell starts ringing inexplicably, my subconscious invents a fire engine to account for it. I discover, upon waking, that it was my alarm clock. Similarly, this lady "explains" the presence of someone walking past by seeing them as a possible guest ("Would you like a cup of tea?") or a friend or relative ("Hello again. What's it like out?").

Who knows what she was, or what she did, before her dementia set in? And how sharply does it put into perspective the concerns which usually occupy us?